Music Fellowship
buy an ad! we need the money more than sally struthers

fakejazz.com
update
last:17jan
next:feb
reviews | articles | search | picks | bands | contact | beta site
10 out of 12 The Coxcomb/Avocado Orange EP cover

David Grubbs - The Coxcomb/Avocado Orange EP
(Blue Chopsticks)

Welcome to your freshman English seminar with Professor Grubbs. This term we will be studying short stories by different American authors.

"The Coxcomb" is an adaptation of the short story "The Blue Hotel" by Stephen Crane (The Red Badge of Courage) and was originally released on an import-only 12" picture disc. Written at the latter part of the 19th Century, "The Blue Hotel" revolves around the stereotypes of the Old West--cowboys, gambling, and fighting--that have long been fascinations for Grubbs. Even at 17 minutes, much of the beautiful language of Crane's story was pruned. However, Grubbs has done a masterful job of turning the story into verse, making the most out of the natural rhythm of the language but never forcing or terribly altering the prose to fit the song.

Grubbs finds the most poetic lines in the story and makes them the focal point of the song. "Think I'm a tenderfoot? Think I been to nowheres?" becomes a chorus in the song, the very Grubbs-like words emphasizing the paranoid fear of the Swede that is the catalyst to the story. At the song's epilogue, the narrator sums the story up beautifully, not offering the full explanation the Easterner does in the original text but rather leaving it simply as "the Gambler wasn't even a noun but only a kind of adverb, only an apex." Without Crane's other words, the meaning here is heavily veiled. It clouds the story, prompting the listener to investigate further, giving the apt prose more beauty once it is deciphered.

As a song, the centerpiece is the singing of the characters. Grubbs provides the voice of the Swede along with Stephen Prina as the Narrator and Sasha Andrè as the Cowboy. The music that accompanies the singing is standard Grubbs guitarwork, repetitive but intricate, with cello, trombones, and saxophone added to help create mood. The contribution of the instruments to the story is minimal though; it helps break up the story into sections, but it is clear Grubbs' intent is to make a song here and not a play or opera. The music does not explode with each punch in the fight or willow at the death of a character.

Also on this release is "Avocado Orange," a new, previously unreleased full band recording of "Onion Orange" off Grubbs' Table of the Elements release Banana Cabbage, Potato Lettuce, Onion Orange. Fans of that album and Grubbs' more droning material will no doubt enjoy this piece. The song uses two guitars (one electric and one sounding much like a harpsichord), saxophone, two drummers, and a synthesizer tone to gradually blossom over the song's 10 minutes as each instrument is added, one-by-one. The song starts with just guitar and synth, then rolling, firecracker drums start to jump around, then the alto sax lets out a few bellows, before finally an electric guitar plays a slow, somber melody.

If you don't have "The Coxcomb" 12", this EP is essential Grubbs. It's a shame, though, that Grubbs did not also include the B-side of that EP on this release as it had already been re-released on an import-only one song 3" CD single. Three songs span three releases, and Grubbs completists still need to buy at least two of them (at least one an import) in order to get all three songs. If you already have "The Coxcomb" 12", find the audio file for the extra song on this EP; it's not worth the money on its own.

jim steed
2001 jan 12

copyright © 2000-4 | fakejazz.com | balacynwyd, pa - newhaven, ct - slc, ut | info@fakejazz.com